The Food and Drug Administration is considering implementing a requirement for prepackaged food sold in America to display key nutrient information on the front of packaging in addition to the existing nutrition label on the back. This concept, already in place in several countries worldwide, aims to provide consumers with quick health information to help them make healthier choices. Advocates have been pushing for front-of-pack labels for nearly two decades, arguing that they can encourage food manufacturers to reformulate their products for better nutrition. The FDA has conducted research on front-of-pack labeling, testing various label designs, but faces opposition from trade associations representing the food and beverage industry who have their own voluntary labeling system in place.
Some of the proposed front-of-pack label designs use traffic light colors to indicate nutrient levels or simply state if a product is high in certain nutrients. However, challenges may arise on First Amendment grounds, particularly with interpretive designs that characterize products as unhealthy. The FDA has not disclosed which label design it will use and the release date of its proposed rule, but it is expected to be in the summer. Trade associations like the Consumer Brands Association and FMI are against mandatory interpretive designs and argue that their voluntary system, Facts up Front, already provides consumers with essential nutrition information on packaging.
Advocates for mandatory front-of-pack labeling believe that the voluntary system is not widely used and lacks context to help consumers interpret information. They argue that to be reliable for consumers, front-of-pack labeling should be applied across the entire food supply, not just on products from manufacturers who opt into a voluntary program. There is debate over whether mandatory front-of-pack labeling will actually improve Americans’ diets, but advocates point to data from countries like Chile where such labeling has led to healthier consumer purchases and product reformulations.
The FDA has reviewed scientific literature on front-of-pack labels and concluded that they can help consumers identify healthy foods, especially those with lower nutrition knowledge and busy shoppers. The discussion around front-of-pack labeling comes as obesity rates in the US continue to rise, with about 42% of adults affected by obesity. The FDA emphasizes the importance of addressing diet-related diseases like cardiovascular disease and diabetes, highlighting the potential benefits of improved nutrition information on packaging. Overall, front-of-pack labeling is seen as a potential tool to help consumers make informed decisions about their food choices, particularly for those with limited time and nutrition literacy.
Discussion about this post