Credit Suisse’s recent decision to exit certain investment banking activities has sparked concern among investors and proxy advisers about potential conflicts of interest involving two directors, Michael Klein and Blythe Masters. Klein, who stepped down from the board to oversee the spin-off of the investment banking business, is set to become the CEO of the new unit in 2023. Ethos Foundation and proxy adviser Actares are questioning the selection process for Klein and Masters’ involvement in the reorganization, fearing they may benefit at the bank’s expense.
Despite the scrutiny, Credit Suisse’s top backers, Harris Associates and Saudi National Bank, support the bank’s governance and handling of potential conflicts of interest. The bank’s decision to raise capital from Saudi National Bank as part of its turnaround plan underscores the close ties between Credit Suisse and Saudi Arabia. However, concerns have been raised about the possibility of Klein combining his advisory boutique, M. Klein & Co, with the newly spun-off unit, CS First Boston, leading to a potential conflict of interest.
The restructuring plan, which includes the spin-off of the investment banking business and the sale of the securitized products unit to Apollo, has been met with both support and skepticism from investors. Credit Suisse’s shares rose following the announcement of the restructuring plan, signaling investor confidence in the bank’s ability to navigate challenges and restore profitability. However, questions remain about the transparency of the decision-making process and the potential for conflicts of interest to arise.
Credit Suisse’s approach to leveraging internal talent for the turnaround plan is not uncommon in European companies, according to corporate law experts. The involvement of conflicted directors in discussions and decision-making processes is accepted practice, but the bank must demonstrate how it manages potential conflicts of interest to maintain trust and transparency. Independent assessments and regulatory scrutiny will be crucial in ensuring that any potential transactions, such as the integration of Klein’s boutique into CS First Boston, are conducted at arm’s length.
As Credit Suisse moves forward with its restructuring plan, it faces the challenge of rebuilding trust with investors and stakeholders. Clear communication, transparent governance practices, and a commitment to addressing potential conflicts of interest will be essential in regaining confidence in the bank’s strategic direction. By navigating these challenges effectively, Credit Suisse can position itself for long-term success and stability in the financial industry.
Discussion about this post